Explanation of OOF and PULL THROUGH Team Strength at the World
Series and how it assists with team classification
In 2003, the
North American Fastpitch Association began using a new method for
examining a team’s performance at the World Series to assist us with
the Classification of teams for the following year based on their
place of finish at the World Series and the relative strength of the
teams that each team played. This combined with our visually
subjective evaluations allowed the NAFA Staff to be more Objective
in determining how many places down in a particular class that we
would bump teams to the next class for the next season.
Although
somewhat technical, these charts from the 2004 and 2005 World Series
events provided by Mike Clark of Iowa continue to be an invaluable
tool for NAFA. This brief description is intended to assist you in
understanding what OOF and Pull Through mean and what the details of
the end product are.
OOF means
Order of Finish or Final Standings of an event. Pull Through means
the system by which we evaluate each team compared to the strength
of the teams that they played based on pulling through each teams
opponents through the bracket and assigning a strength to each
opponent based on how they finished in the event and based on how
they competed against other teams in the event and especially
against the top teams in the event.
The process
starts when we send the completed brackets with game scores to Mike
Clark at the conclusion of each World Series Bracket. Mike Clark
then does the rest of the work which is the technical and most
difficult part. First he calculates the record of each team and
their final placement in the bracket. 1st,2nd,
3rd, 4th, 5th(2), 7th)(2),
9th(4), 13th(4), 17th(8), 25th(8)
and so on until each team is labeled with its final order of finish.
Each group is assigned a point total for their place of finish, i.e.
1st-4th 8 points, 5th-6th
7 points, 7th-8th 6 points, 9th-12th
5 points, 13th-16th 4 points, 17th-24th
3 points, 25th-32nd 2 points, and so on.
Then
the teams are organized in each place category by their level of
advancement and by wins and losses. Then they are separated if tied
by run differential. This information is inserted into an excel
document and the excel spreadsheet calculates the total points a
team earns for the whole event which is weighted by the number of
games they played and more importantly it assigns a per game point
average which the Executive Committee uses to compare what we saw
with our eyes and what the objective OOF and Pull Through calculated
for each team’s comparative strength to each other.
I hope
this description helps but if you are totally confused after
examining the results of 2004 and 2005 then email Mike Clark at
mclark434@mchsi.com and he will be glad to
answer your questions. We hope that by sharing this information with
the players that they join us in developing fair methods to evaluate
and classify teams each year based on their World Series
performancewhich is by no means the only method but is an important
part of the process. I will try to describe above each class of play
what we ended up doing for reclassification for the next year.